top of page

Rights in The Shadows: The Abuse of Homeless


In recent years, stories of individuals being mistreated or displaced within the confines of homeless shelters have surfaced around the country. Countless vulnerable lives are affected by the lack of adequate legal protection for those seeking refuge in these establishments.


The plight of the homeless is an ever-present issue, yet it often evades the spotlight or elicits only a half-hearted response from authorities. It is time to bring the abuse and maltreatment within some homeless shelters into the light, where neglect is replaced by compassion, and the darkness of bureaucracy fades before the dawn of compassion.



The undertaking to provide safe shelter for the homeless population is a noble endeavor, shelters such as The Light of Life Rescue Mission, Pleasant Valley Men's Shelter, and The Resolve treatment center in Pittsburgh PA genuinely hold the welfare and treatment of their residents in high regard. But others operate with the stated uncaring sentiment telling residents, if you don't like the way we treat you, you can go back to living under a bridge. 


We still find ourselves falling short. I have borne witness to residents of shelters sent adrift by the cold and callous actions of shelter administrators. I have reported extensively on the heart-wrenching story of an eight-month-pregnant woman, a fragile mother-to-be – both helpless and hopeless, expelled from the only semblance of a home she possessed. This instance of inhumanity occurred long after we, as a society, should have moved past this level of neglect for our fellow human beings.



Our local politicians and government agencies, rather than taking responsibility, reiterated that shelters have the "right" to forcibly remove anyone for any reason at any given time. In neglecting the core idea of protection and safety for the homeless, are we not delving further into a quagmire of inequality and insensitivity? Homelessness is a multidimensional issue that is often swept under the rug, a problem many cities around the world struggle to tackle. The lack of legal protection for homeless people living in shelters not only leaves them vulnerable to exploitation but also deepens their already dire situation. The implementation of a legal framework would ensure that the rights of these individuals are protected and that they have recourse against any improper treatment or neglect.



Analyzing the Legal Landscape

Homeless shelters are governed by a loose set of rules and regulations, often described as inadequate in protecting the rights of their residents.


Recently, the UN Special Report on the right to adequate housing highlighted the importance of a legal framework to ensure that individuals have access to emergency and long-term housing solutions. Homeless individuals, advocates, and organizations have long voiced their concerns over the situation and expressed the need for urgent legal reforms.



Unheard Echoes: The Plight of the Homeless and Their Advocates

Through encounters with nonprofit organizations aiding the homeless and intimate conversations with those residing in shelters, a mosaic of perspectives, raw and unfiltered, emerges. At the helm, homeless advocates fervently campaign to fortify the legal infrastructure, shielding the vulnerable from further exploitation and cruelty. The voices of the homeless resonate with their pleas, recounting spine-chilling tales of anguish and injustice endured.


When delving into the daily existence of these individuals, one cannot help but question the safety and stability, and the assurance that every citizen is encompassed by the same rights and dignity. Our revered Bill of Rights boldly proclaims to safeguard the defenseless within our society. Yet, the homeless, forsaken and relegated to the shadows, epitomize vulnerability. A pregnant woman yearning for refuge, a victim fleeing domestic abuse, a soul seeking solace from addiction or simply respite from the biting cold and a morsel of sustenance all are rendered defenseless as they are forsaken to the unforgiving streets, their rights trampled upon under the weight of arbitrary regulations and apathetic policies.


The Path Forward

While the situation may be bleak, a concerted effort by the government, nonprofit organizations, and society at large can galvanize the discussion surrounding legal protections for homeless individuals in shelters. By providing vulnerable individuals with a stable environment, we can move toward a world where pregnant women are no longer cast out into the cold, and no one has to suffer for lack of shelter.


The primary goal of homeless shelters should be to provide a safe space for vulnerable individuals, but the lack of a standardized legal system in place leaves room for inconsistencies and potential abuse. An established legal framework would provide both protection for the rights of the homeless living in shelters and guidance for shelter staff to ensure quality care.


Organizations like the National Coalition for the Homeless and the National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty advocate on the matter but struggle to develop significant change without a comprehensive federal legal system in place.



Individuals and advocates within the homeless community express concerns over potential abuse and neglect inside some shelters. James, a homeless man from New York City, reported that "the staff sometimes mistreats us. Shelter Administrators know there are no legal repercussions for mistreating shelter residents and few avenues exist to receive the complaints of the homeless.  


Anne Marshall*, who works with a non-profit organization specializing in homeless services, sees the need for a unified legal system, stating, "It's important to establish a baseline of rights for everyone in shelters, regardless of their background. We witness major differences in the way people are treated based on the shelters they visit."


The Positive & Negative Aspects

One positive aspect of the current situation is the increased involvement of non-profit organizations, volunteers, and philanthropists who donate time, money, and resources to help those in need. The issue has caught the attention of the public and even celebrities like Rihanna, who has donated millions to help combat homelessness.


However, the lack of legal protection for the homeless in shelters persists, and if not appropriately addressed, those most in need may continue to face negative experiences in these supposed "safe havens."


Case Studies

In San Francisco, a city famous for its homelessness crisis, the Integrated Homelessness Response System (IHRS) has improved accountability and streamlined services by connecting providers, sharing data, and focusing on results. IHRS has been commended for its coordinated approach, although it does not include specific legal protection for the homeless in shelters.


Conclusion

The United States must address the lack of a standardized federal legal framework to protect the rights of homeless people living in shelters. Federal legislation that ensures shelters are mandated to treat their residents with dignity and respect and that the resident's rights are explained to them in detail when they enter the shelter. And legal protections from abuse must be guaranteed.


For media inquiries, please contact:


UK - 020 3404 2295

USA - 0650 278 4440

AUS - 02 9072 9499


All of our writers risk it all by telling their stories and any support you can provide will make a big difference. Firstly by showing them that there words matter, but also by helping them keep the lights on and food in their bellies. Donate if you can and know every dollar goes to supporting our writers and authors.


11 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page